Shopify: theme settings, an app, or custom Liquid? How to decide
Picture a hypothetical store that didn't get messy on purpose. Someone needed a size chart, so an app went in. Then a countdown banner, then a "frequently bought together" block, then reviews. A year later the store has eight apps, a monthly bill nobody has added up, and a product page that loads scripts from half a dozen places.
None of those decisions were wrong on their own. The problem is that there are three different ways to add something to a Shopify store, and they tend to get picked by habit rather than by fit.
The three options
1. Your theme's own settings. Modern Shopify themes are built from sections and blocks that you can add, remove and reorder in the theme editor, on most page types including product pages. A surprising amount of "I need an app for that" is already a block in your theme: image-with-text, collapsible rows for shipping info, icon lists, custom content per template.
2. An app. Apps are the right answer when the feature needs to do something outside the page: store data, run on a schedule, talk to another service, process orders, send email. Reviews, subscriptions, loyalty points, accounting sync and shipping rules are app territory. Many apps now add their storefront pieces as app blocks you place in the theme editor, rather than editing your theme code.
3. A custom Liquid section. Liquid is the template language Shopify themes are written in. A custom section is a small file added to your theme that renders exactly the layout you want, with its own settings so you can still edit text and images in the theme editor afterwards. It's right when the feature is mostly presentation: a size guide driven by product metafields, a comparison table, a branded landing section, a store-specific trust panel.
A quick way to decide
Ask these in order:
- Can a block in my current theme already do this? Check the theme editor and your theme's documentation first. Free and obvious beats clever.
- Does it need to store data, run in the background or connect to another system? If yes, it's probably an app. Building that from scratch rarely makes sense for a small store.
- Is it just showing information I already have (product details, metafields, collection data) in a particular layout? That's a good candidate for a custom section.
- Will I still be paying for it in three years? A $15/month app is $540 over three years. Sometimes that's excellent value. Sometimes it's paying rent on a table.
The tradeoffs, honestly
Apps are fast to install and someone else maintains them. The costs: a recurring fee, another vendor's script on your page (which can affect speed), and leftover code if an older app edited your theme directly and wasn't cleaned up on uninstall.
Custom Liquid has no app subscription and can be scoped to only what you need. It still costs development time up front and maintenance later, and it isn't automatically fast: badly written Liquid, heavy images or extra scripts can slow a page as easily as an app. It also lives in your theme. If you switch to a new theme later, custom sections need to be moved across and checked. That's normally manageable when it's done properly as a self-contained section with settings, rather than code pasted into the middle of a theme file.
Theme settings cost nothing, but you're limited to what the theme author anticipated.
Before you change anything: a checklist
- Duplicate your live theme and work on the copy. Publish only when you've checked it.
- List every installed app with its monthly cost and what it actually does on the storefront.
- Uninstall apps you don't use and check whether they left snippets behind in your theme.
- Use metafields for product-specific content (care instructions, dimensions, ingredients) so a section can display it consistently instead of copy-pasting it into each description.
- Test on a phone as well as a desktop, and check your own analytics to see which devices your customers actually use.
- Keep custom code in sections and snippets, named clearly, so the next developer (or you) can find it.
Where I fit in
I build Shopify stores and write custom Liquid sections and themes. Often the most useful thing I can do in a first conversation is tell you which of your current apps you could drop, and which ones are genuinely earning their fee. If a theme setting already does the job, I'll say so.
If your store has grown a few too many apps, or there's a layout you can't get your theme to do, get in touch and tell me what you're trying to show.